Quote of the Day provided by The Free Library


Friday, June 08, 2007

Trolley By Golly!

By Mark Forsythe
The Kansas City Post

Way back in the 1980's the city of Galveston, Texas decided to build a trolley system to link their downtown arts district with the sea wall. The idea was that a trolley would be an additional tourist attraction and would aid in circulating visitors unfamiliar with the area. Because of the historic nature of many of the buildings and streetscapes they decided to employ a self-propelled system so as not to mar the area with overhead wires and their supporting infrastructure. The second reason was the gulf coast location. Hurricanes tend to blow down overhead wires. Ask the city of New Orleans. Their St. Charles line trolley is still not running because they haven't had the time and money to repair the overhead wires. Galveston surmised that after a major hurricane, all they would have to do is remove debris from the tracks and their transit system would be back up and running.

The system cost $20 Million dollars to build. This included four custom built trolleys, the track, a maintenance facility and the necessary operational funds to begin service. $10 Million dollars came from UMTA Federal grant funds, with the remaining required local match of $10 Million coming from the State of Texas and two private foundations.

Against much opposition, the trolleys began operating in 1988. Then something unexpected happened. The trolleys became much more than the "touristy frou-frou" they were designed to be. Turns out the locals started using them for lunchtime jaunts, shopping, errands and in some cases commuting. Pretty good for 2.1 mile loop. Now Galveston had a problem. Albeit a good one. They were faced with turning a tourist attraction into a legitimate transit system. In 1995 the route was expanded and the entire system turned over to the local bus system to operate. In 2005 the system was expanded once again. This time a 1.5 mile branch to the University of Texas Medical Campus. Touristy frou-frou had gone legit.

Could the same success happen for Kansas City? Maybe, maybe not. We don't have a built-in attraction like an ocean. We do have venues around downtown that draw people back and forth though. The KCRTA in conjunction with the Downtown Council is looking at a trolley system for downtown. Completely separate from the light rail debacle, er I mean plan, our trolleys would be much like the Galveston system. Touristy frou-frou.

If I was made "Trolley King" for a day, I think I would run a line right down 12th Street, across the bridge and into the West Bottoms. Why? The American Royal for one. Second? Up and over the second bridge and back around W 9th St. for the clubs, art and architecture galleries and haunted houses.

Now I realize we don't have $20 million lying around to blow on trolleys, but if cities like Galveston can be creative with technology and financing, why can't we?

Comments on "Trolley By Golly!"

 

Blogger Xavier Onassis said ... (12:05 PM) : 

There used to be trolleys downtown.

What happened to them?

 

Anonymous eastsider said ... (8:44 PM) : 

XO: I think a number of them were sold to Philadelphia(sp?) and some may still be in use.I remember seeing a couple of them in a junk yard in the west bottoms. That was in the 70's

 

Anonymous Anonymous said ... (9:00 PM) : 

You had me until the end. west bottoms? for a couple weekends a year?

How about a figure 8 (if that's possible). Broadway, Grand, Prospect as N/S streets. Independence Ave, 5th, and 18th as E/W streets.

18th and Vine, City Market, Sprint Center, PAC, P&L, Bartle, Crossroads...and good for locals especially east siders.

 

Anonymous eastsider said ... (9:49 PM) : 

mark

A tourist trolley has a lot going for it. But it is going to have to pass the Clinton Adams test and most of the ideas proposed by folks like the Urban society don't even come close. Your 18th and vine spur came close but would touch on a sore nerve by using the 3rd district for heavy industrial(we're good enough for your junk yards but not good enough for.....)

My wife and I were discussing this with friends the other day and your trolley would work perfect for her idea. She would like to see a loop around down town that connnected all the major developements the city has been pouring money into: City market, Convention center/entertainment district, union station/ liberty memorial and the jazz district. She would like it to go down Broadway to Pershing, Pershing then 22nd to Paseo, Paseo to Independence Avenue, then Independence Ave by the city market back to broadway.

The advantage of a tourist trolly is the easy sell, "go downtown" ect.. It could be solded as a part of an economic development package. By turning and going north from the Jazz district you have your best chance of passing the Clinton Adams test and getting east side neighborhoods to support you. Old Northeast would support you if you pointed out the possibility of a major shopping mall going in east of the interstate along side the trolley route. Throw in downtown, crossroads and all the people like you who would just like to see any kind of rail and you just might win.

 

Blogger Mark said ... (7:35 AM) : 

XO,

Eastsider is right. The majority of KC's streetcars were sold to Philly.

Eastsider,

I wasn't looking at offloading "heavy industrial" on the 3rd District. I was advocating a maintenance center in an existing light industrial park that would bring some good jobs. Did I miss something? I thought that was a good thing.

Keep in mind when I'm talking about tourist trolleys I'm talking about something completely separate from the light rail plan. As such, I think exploring private endowments and federal CMAQ grants might be an option.

I realize the 12th St route is a line to nowhere but it's a start.

 

Anonymous Anonymous said ... (9:44 AM) : 

Everyone in KC knows you can't run a tourist trolley east of Troost. The tourists will get killed and "those people" will come downtown to hang out and buy crack.
How about instead of a tourist trolley, we build a 20 foot high tourist-protection seawall down Troost?

 

Anonymous Mr. Wishy Washy said ... (9:26 AM) : 

Could the same success happen for Kansas City? Maybe, maybe not.

Yeah! Take a stand and stick to it.

 

Anonymous Michelled said ... (10:15 AM) : 

We can overcome the 'Troost stigma' easily if Olathe can shed its white trash image and become a place people actually CHOOSE to move to. He!!, the New York Times even wrote up an article with the mayor bragging about the high housing costs...my how times have changed.

 

Anonymous Michelled said ... (10:23 AM) : 

The Trolley idea is a no brainer...we just need to make sure they're reliable. People continue to get stranded by nimrods that decide they're going to change the routes for peak transit times and leaving folks stranded - St. Patties, River Mkt concerts, Plaza Lighting to name a few.

Yes, there is already a maintence facility just outside the 18th & Vine area and tons of under used space that could be used WITHOUT detracting from the area. Of course, they could have put in the Costco/Home Depot without detracting from the area but they didn't...

 

Blogger Mark said ... (4:19 PM) : 

If anything comes out of researching this, it will be that I now want to visit Galveston for a vacation. It looks like a lot of fun.

Last Christmas we spent in New Orleans. Maybe this year Texas?

 

Anonymous Millie said ... (8:11 AM) : 

Why so expensive? Twenty million dollars for two miles of track? It seems pretty basic to me. Especially without the overhead wires. Am I missing something?

 

post a comment
Google
WWW The Kansas City Post