Curbside Recycling: We can do better
By Mark Forsythe The Kansas City Post Yesterday I threw away a glass bottle. I'm sure a large percentage of Kansas Citians do this every day without a second thought but to an ardent recycler like myself it borders on the sacrilegious. The combination of $4/gallon gasoline and the loss of the midtown recycling center has made it a losing proposition to haul a few pounds of glass all the way out to 95th and Hillcrest. I'm reasonably certain it's a net carbon loss to burn that much fuel and emit that much pollution from my tailpipe to recycle a couple of pounds of glass. It seems we've come a long way only to fall back a few steps. Years ago a KC resident could contract individually with Deffenbaugh to have their recycling picked up curbside. They accepted paper, plastic and glass. Soon city leaders decided this should be a free service to all residents. Admirable in intent, but poor in implementation. Citing "hazard" and "insurance purposes" glass was excluded from the City's curbside pickup. Of course nobody seemed to notice that it was still Deffenbaugh doing the pickups. One day, glass was acceptable, the next it was a hazard too dangerous to handle by the very same employees? What about the hazard of that glass now lying broken and hidden within a trash bag ready to puncture the bag and an unfortunate sanitation worker's skin? I have some personal experience with this just hauling trash bags to the curb. Fortunately I decided not to sue myself for negligence. With everybody piling on the green bandwagon, now would seem a good time to revisit our recycling policies. Attempting to ban plastic water bottles City Hall is a nice gesture, but it falls far short of any meaningful progress. Having a councilperson come to my homes association board meeting and tell us about the evils of plastic bottles while she drank from a plastic bottle she had just purchased didn't do much in the way of inspiring people to a good cause. Something needs to be done to let those of us concerned with the environment to recycle our glass easily. Be it through City Hall, or a private contractor that I would pay for on my own. It seems the prevailing attitude regarding new ideas is "we can't." Frankly I've grown tired of the "we can't" crowd. Unfortunately that crowd still runs this town. I think it's time we stop reinforcing everything "we can't" do and start concentrating on what we "can" do. |






Comments on "Curbside Recycling: We can do better"
-
Brent said ... (9:07 AM) :
-
Eric Rogers said ... (9:10 AM) :
-
Alan Birch said ... (9:51 AM) :
-
Anonymous said ... (4:00 PM) :
-
Anonymous said ... (10:28 PM) :
-
Jim said ... (9:16 AM) :
-
Mark said ... (10:20 AM) :
-
Capt. Geoffrey Spaulding said ... (10:59 AM) :
-
Anonymous said ... (5:23 PM) :
-
Eric Rogers said ... (7:38 AM) :
-
Anonymous said ... (9:28 AM) :
-
Mark said ... (12:31 PM) :
-
Mark said ... (12:36 PM) :
-
Mark said ... (12:40 PM) :
-
Midtown Miscreant said ... (8:41 AM) :
post a commentIt seems like having more than 2 drop off points for glass in the entire city would be a good place to start. Seems like we could start having multiple glass drop-off places around the city, and then, eventually, work our way into curbside.
There are actually three places to drop-off glass - north, south, and central.
Before adding glass, we ought to be recycling universally available. The city still refuses to offer recycling for multi-family buildings, even though those residents pay the same earnings tax as the folks in single-family houses.
It's pretty dumb for the city to encourage people to move back into the urban core and then not offer basic city services like recycling.
I thought that the energy cost of reheating recycled glass to melt it down and reuse it was more expensive than just digging up some sand and making new glass.
If you're looking for another place to drop off glass, Boulevard Brewery has a drop-off container. I've heard that they are taking glass and using it to make beer bottles.
I used to recycle glass until I was advised by a BFI rep that none of the glass drop-off places in KC actually recycle glass. They just smash it up and stick it in landfills. So I asked an EPA employee I know, and she corroborated the rep's story, claiming the closest place that actually melted down glass for recycling was somewhere near Chicago, and that what we did here amounted to smashing it up and burying it in the hopes that someday someone will dig it up.
I've been assuming for a while that this was all true, but I suppose it's possible that these people are both horribly misinformed. Anyone else heard this?
@Anonymous:
I've heard the same thing too, except the closest place was somewhere in Tennessee. Why don't we recycle our glass bottles? Glass has a high melting temp so why not run them through an autoclave?
Still, KC can do better on recycling...but how about instead of us all bitching on blogs (I'm most guilty) we write a letter or something. Just an idea.
Recently NPR had a story about recyclebank.com.
Their business model seems to be a win-win for residents and the company doing the pick-ups.
Their expansion to the KC area wouldn't be a charitable decision... rather one based on the business' viability here.
If you're a business owner that can benefit from a partnership with them or a consumer that would like to participate, it couldn't hurt to advocate for them through civic channels.
Jim,
Thank you for the information on recyclebank.com. Can't believe I missed an NPR story! It looks like they're East coast only right now.
Anony's,
I hadn't heard the story about the glass not being recycled. I will check into that.
Well- we take all of our glass- brown- green & clear- to the recycling center at the old WalMart Supercenter at 9051 Chuck Eddy (Hillcrest).
I assumed they recycled the glass- but apparently not- according to your other commenters.
"Green" Cheers!
-Groucho
Glass can be recycled an indefinite number of times, much moreso than plastic.
I believe curbside glass is a safety issue because of the risk to the people collecting glass/broken glass from the containers.
Looks like Boulevard might be trying to make matters into their own hands with glass recycling.
http://kansascity.bizjournals.com/kansascity/stories/2008/08/18/focus15.html?b=1219032000^1683931
The arguement made to the Council at the time of the recyling program was that Deffenbaugh was implementing a new "sorting" system/technology and that glass would contaminate this system.
Also, keep in mind that those of us in the "we can" mindset had to overcome a host of objections to even implement the current recycling program. I was told on a number of occasions that what I proposed couldn't be done ("we can't"); implementing a comprehensive curbside recycling program without a tax increase.
I completely agree that an expansion of the program is needed and what we need is leadership from a Councilperson willing to say "we can" and then have the capacity and skill to see it through the legislative process.
Jim
I checked into the glass not being recycled. It's partially true. Not all the glass is shipped to Oklahoma (the closest glass recycling plant). Two reasons. First is capacity. The OK plant only needs so much raw material. Second it cost. That's a lot of bucks to ship glass hundreds of miles. So the truth lies somewhere in between. We ship and recycle what we can. The rest, unfortunately goes in the dump.
The good news is talks are underway for the establishment of a local billet plant. Billets are glass raw material so if we get a local plant the shipping cost problem is out of the picture.
Eric,
I'm excited about Boulevard's potential plans. I'm trying to get in contact with someone there to see if they'll support some legislation I'm going to help work up having to do with renewable energy incentives. If anybody out there has a contact within Boulevard, please give them my email!
Jim,
Thanks for the explanation about Deffenbaugh's sorting change. I forgot about that.
I'm glad we agree that we can do better!
By the way, while I have your attention, when are we going to see some of these around the TSC?
http://forsythe4kc.com/2008/08/another-gift-idea.html
I was in the recycling biz in springfield, though its been over 10 years ago. The problem with glass back then was a lack of markets, contamination and always cost. not much has changed .